Odd behavior installing ubuntu-desktop on Ubuntu 22.04 and LXD 22.04 containers

LXD
#1

I encountered some odd behavior with Ubuntu 22.04 and LXD.

Simple use-case:
On 22.04 Host create a 22.04 LXD container
Install any one of the Ubuntu “flavor’s” Desktops into the container

=======================================================

Create an ubuntu 22.04 container

apt update

apt upgrade -y

apt install ubuntu-desktop -y

this will eventually experience a variety of failures ending with no desktop installed in the 22.04 container

=======================================================

Create an Ubuntu 20.04 container

apt update

apt upgrade -y

apt install ubuntu-desktop -y

This will successfully install the desktop into the 20.04 container.

=======================================================

NOTE:

You can repeat the above scenario trying to install any of the
Ubuntu Flavor’s Desktops.

  • ubuntu-desktop
  • ubuntu-mate-desktop
  • lubuntu-desktop
  • kde-standard
  • kubuntu-desktop
  • xubuntu-desktop
  • ubuntu-budgie-desktop
  • cinnamon-desktop-environment

They all end the same:

  • Failure in the 22.04 container.
  • Success in the 20.04 container.

So there is something wrong with either the LXD 22.04 container images
or
with the Packaging of all the 22.04 “desktop” installation packages (seems unlikely)

I also just spun up an Ubuntu 22.04 Server and after reboot

$ sudo apt install ubuntu-desktop -y

and it too successfully installed the desktop !

#2

@tomp
Tom I can file a bug but against what? LXD 22.04 Ubuntu images?

#3

Well the grub issue has nothing to do with LXD, so is there something for grub?

#4

Sorry I’m confused… “grub issue” ??

I was asking about the fact that attempts to install any Ubuntu “flavor” Desktop in a 22.04 Container fails but succeeds in 20.04 containers and succeeds if installing a Desktop on a 22.04 Server.

#5

Oh I confused your threads.

You’ve not supplied any error messages so I don’t know how we can progress the issue without some more detail I’m afraid.

#6

I have some of them captured so I’ll send them when I get back to my PC.

Brian

#7

I can confirm. I performed an

apt install ubuntu-desktop -y

on a LXD container running Ubuntu 22.04.

image
image1763×324 61.7 KB

#8

Yes that’s the same type error I’m seeing

I captured all the various errors yesterday. It took 5+ hrs to run the

# apt install ubuntu-desktop -y

Below are the error messages from:

HOST: Ubuntu 22.04

LXD Container: Ubuntu 22.04

Command executed in Container: # apt install ubuntu-desktop -y

These are just the errors that occurred.

NOTE: same command executed in a 20.04 Container succeeds with NO errors.

First error that occurs is acpi-support (timeout is maybe 19 min)::

image.png

Next error that occurs is with openvpn (timeout takes maybe 8-10 min).

image.png

Next error that occurs is with “woopsie”… but the timeout takes 20+ min?

image.png

Next…(another 5+ min timeout)

image.png

Next… (another 15+ min timeout)

image.png

Next…

image.png

Next…

image.png

Next…

image.png

Next…

image.png

The ubuntu-desktop installation finally FAILS (run time 5hrs) !

image.png

Host machine:

  • Intel i7
  • 32GB RAM
  • 2TB SSD
#9

Do you get these same errors when running with a LXD VM rather than a container?

#10

@sdeziel does that look like the issue where we need a limits bump for some kernel limit?

#11

Perhaps. Also if I create a LXD container with Ubuntu 22.04 and I try to nest Docker inside it, with the Docker install script:

curl -sSL https://get.docker.com | sh

it fails also even with the nesting flag set to true. Nesting Docker inside an Ubuntu 20.04 LXD container works great with the same script.

image
image1840×472 101 KB

#12

At this point, the logs are filled with thousands of repeats of systemd[1]: Condition check resulted in ACPI event daemon being skipped. which could explain the slowness and the eventual timeout.

#13

Here’s a workaround that made 22.04 work for me:

apt-get install -y acpid
systemctl disable --now acpid.service acpid.socket acpid.path
apt install ubuntu-desktop -y

With the above, there is no log about Condition check resulted in ACPI event daemon being skipped which I find weird.

Update: the acpid.service has the following condition:

# systemctl cat acpid | grep Condition
ConditionVirtualization=!container
1 Like
#14

It seems to be a bug with acpid:

Until this is fixed in Ubuntu, one can pre-install acpid and systemctl disable --now acpid.path to avoid the endless log loop.

2 Likes
#15

But in my case acpi-support is just the first of many “fails”

If it’s the root cause of all the others that would be good too.

#16

@bmullan, I followed your reproducer and with my workaround, the ubuntu-desktop install goes smoothly. Could you please try it and report back?

#17

Sure I’ll do that today.

Brian

#18

Yes, the work-around steps:

> apt-get install -y acpid
> systemctl disable --now acpid.service acpid.socket acpid.path
> apt install ubuntu-desktop -y

Let the ubuntu-desktop install complete successfully.

Hopefully the root cause can be addressed so the work-around isn’t needed in the future.

#19

@sdeziel

Whatever the “root-cause” of this bug was not fixed/released yet in 22.04.1.

Luckily, your workaround still works :sweat_smile:

brian mullan